Skip to content

Accountability:
Toward a Culture of
0ABUSE in the Congregation
of the Legionaries of Christ

Cardinal Velasio de Paolis creates the Comission for outreach to victims of Marcial Maciel
Highlights the need to reach out to victims and seek reconciliation and communicates about the founders. Work begins on the prevention of abuses and in dealing with accusations.
Safe Environment standards take effect
Regnum Christi Statutes take effect

INTERVENTION OF THE HOLY SEE CONCLUDES
2011
2014
General Chapter
2015
September
2019
Report
1941 - 2019
of the Legionaries of Christ on sexual abuse from its foundation to the present
Chapter Document
"Conversion and Reparation"
Chapter Document "Protect and Heal"
2020 Annual Report Truth, Justice and Healing,
2021 Annual Report Truth, Justice and Healing,
December 21, 2019
February 2020
February 2020
March 2021
April 2022

Accountability
0abuse.org

2011
Cardinal Velasio de Paolis creates the Comission for outreach to victims of Marcial Maciel
2014 General Chapter
Highlights the need to reach out to victims and seek reconciliation and communicates about the founders. Work begins on the prevention of abuses and in dealing with accusations.
2015
Safe Environment standards take effect
2019 September
Regnum Christi Statutes take effect
INTERVENTION OF THE HOLY SEE CONCLUDES
2019 December
Report 1941 - 2019 of the Legionaries of Christ on sexual abuse from its oundation to the present December 21, 2019
2020 February 26
Chapter Document "Conversion and Reparation"
2020 February 26
Chapter Document "Protect and Heal"
March 2021
2020 I Annual Report Truth, Justice and Healing,
April 2022
2021 II Annual Report Truth, Justice and Healing,
Accountability

Global statistics on Abuse Cases 1941-2022

The following statistics present cases of sexual abuse of minors by Legionary of Christ priests, from the Congregation’s founding in 1941 to March 28, 2022. They are verified cases, not statistical projections.

1. Historical overview

There are 28 cases verified by admission, a civil trial, a canonical proceeding endorsed by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, or a declaration from the appropriate major superior. Of these priests, 17 remain in the Congregation (one of whom has been removed from the clerical state). All of these cases have been presented to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and dealt with according to their directions. Four have died, six have left the priesthood and the Congregation, and one has left the Congregation. Of the 17 who remain in the Congregation, 15 exercise no public priestly ministry; two exercise restricted ministry that excludes pastoral work with minors (schools, youth groups, etc.).

  • Civilly, of the 28 priests, three died without being tried, three have been convicted in criminal courts. The others, so far, have not been prosecuted for various reasons, such as the legal situation in the respective countries or because the statute of limitations has elapsed.
  • Canonically, of the 28 priests, the Congregation has asked the Holy See to lift the statute of limitations on eight of them so that they can be tried. Of the 28, two died without being tried, 20 were sanctioned, one received a dispensation from ministry without trial, and five are currently undergoing canonical proceedings.

Therefore, the total number of priests of the Legionaries of Christ who have committed sexual abuse against a person under 18 years old is 28. They represent 2% of the 1,408 ordained Legionary priests throughout the entire history of the Congregation.

Chart2_english
2. Pathways to reconciliation with victims

2.1 Outreach to victims by the Congregation

The Congregation is committed to seeking and taking pathways of truth, justice, and healing for each victim, while respecting the tempo and particular circumstances of each one. This includes those whose cases have already been juridically closed, since the pain of the victims continues after the closure of the case.

 

  • There are around 170 minors, to our knowledge, who were victims of sexual abuse committed by these 28 priests.
  • The majority of the victims were adolescent boys between the ages of 11 and 16.
  • The Congregation has made progress on the pathway to reparation and reconciliation with around 60 of these victims of priests of the Congregation, seeking to facilitate this journey for all victims who should desire it.

The institutional channel for bringing forward allegations can be found here: https://www.0abusos.org/ambientes-seguros/

Chart1_english

2.2 An independent channel to listen to, receive, and assist victims

To offer victims adequate reception and accompaniment, in 2020 the Congregation of the Legionaries of Christ established a permanent partnership with Eshmá, an external and independent institution founded by persons who have first-hand experience of the victimization of child sexual abuse and by therapists, social workers and lawyers who are experts in restorative justice. It specializes in caring for the victims of sexual abuse, abuse of power and of conscience in the Catholic Church and works with various institutions. The Congregation partners with Eshmá and other independent reporting channels in the countries where it is present.

On December 31, 2021, Eshmá was attending 31 victims of members of the Congregation. Of these, 19 came forward after the publication of the 1st Annual Report (March 2021) 

  • 20 persons reported abuses that they suffered as minors
  • 11 reported abuses of power and of conscience as adults. Four of them alleged that there was also behavior that could be considered sexual abuse, given the vulnerable situation they found themselves in.

The identity of the individuals and the information regarding the abuse they have suffered is only shared with the Congregation if the victims so desire it.

The independent international channel for care for victims and bringing forward allegations is Eshmá.

Webpage: eshma.eus
E-mail: escuchamos@eshma.eus
Phone / WhatsApp / Telegram: +34 615 26 36 99

Chart3_english
3. Ongoing follow-up of allegations received since December 2019
  • Four allegations received between December 2019 and March 2021 (1st Annual Report):
    • One is awaiting a ruling from the Holy See after having concluded the canonical criminal trial.
    • One is awaiting a ruling from the Holy See after having concluded the preliminary canonical investigation.
    • Two are under preliminary canonical investigation prior to an eventual canonical trial.
  • Four allegations received between March 2021 and March 2022 (2nd Annual Report).
    • One is awaiting the conclusion of civil and canonical proceedings.
    • Three are under investigation prior to an eventual canonical trial.

Of these eight priests, six are currently removed from public priestly ministry and two exercise a restricted ministry that excludes pastoral work with minors (schools, youth groups, etc.).

Furthermore, new claims, allegations and formal declarations have been received during the canonical proceedings of priests which had already been published in the previous reports in relation to events of past decades. 

Furthermore, a previous case mentioned in the 1941-2019 Report is awaiting the results of a police investigation.

4. Global Statistics of Abuse of Minors by Seminarians of the Congregation.

Sixty of the 74 Legionaries (81.08%) that the 1941-2019 Report identified as allegedly abusing minors when they were novices or religious in formation were not ordained as priests in the Congregation. It has been confirmed in the last three years that there are seven cases of Legionaries who abused as seminarians and were ordained priests. Of these cases, one has died, three are without public priestly ministry, and three have left the priesthood. Two of these seven also abused as priests.

Abuse cases

In addition to the steps already taken and those yet to come, publishing cases of Legionaries who committed abuse is a commitment that seeks to contribute to paving a way toward truth, justice, and healing for victims, as well as solidifying a culture of zero abuse in the Congregation and in society.

The territorial directors published in 2021 the account of every case of sexual abuse against minors that has occurred throughout the history of the Congregation in the countries that today form part of their respective Territories.

Country
Link
Brasil
See
Chile
See
Colombia-Venezuela
See
France
See
Spain
See
United States
See
Central Europe
See
Ireland
See
Italy
See
México
See

The Main Reasons for Publication

Whether publishing the names of those who have abused minors is legitimate and appropriate is widely debated in society and in the Church. Both legal and ethical arguments come into play, leading to a great diversity of legitimate positions.  In applying the criteria established by the 2020 General Chapter to the publication of cases,   the superiors of the Congregation considered several factors: the good of the persons who suffered abuse, the reform of those who committed abuse, the good of the Church and of society, all while observing applicable civil laws.

The main reasons for publishing are listed below, aware that they do not apply in the same way in all cases.

For the sake of known and unknown victims, publication may have the following effects:
  • As an objective acknowledgement of the abuse, it can facilitate the healing process for victims.
  •  It contributes to restoring justice and making reparation when a victim has not been adequately attended to or has even been slandered.
  •  It encourages other potential victims to come forward and receive support, if they so wish, helping them overcome more easily the natural difficulty reporting such an allegation may present.
  •  It makes clear that the priest in question no longer exercises any public priestly ministry, relieving victims of the concern that he could abuse again.
For the sake of the reform of the priest who abused, publication may have the following effects:
  • It can help him become more aware of what he has done, encouraging him to repent and amend his ways.
  • It facilitates his collaboration in reparation efforts and restorative encounters.
  • It helps him comply with the sanctions and restrictions imposed on him.
For the good of society and the people whom the Congregation serves pastorally, the publication of cases of abuse may have the following effects:
  • It underlines our strong repulsion for any abusive behavior.
  • It raises awareness of abuse in general, but also in specific situations, preventing the risk of further abuse.
  • It helps the Congregation fulfill its duty to protect the minors under its care, and youth in general.
  • It informs society about the priests found guilty of abuse and who no longer have public ministry.
  •  It prevents the scandal of holding up as an example a priest known to the Congregation as having committed abuse.
  • It contributes to healing the societal wounds caused by institutional behavior and to creating dynamics in society that foster a culture of care and protection of minors.
For the good of the members of the Congregation, the publication may have the following effects:
  • It contributes to living in truth and acting in a manner consistent with the commitments the Congregation made at the 2020 General Chapter, addressing and healing the personal and structural wounds the abuse caused.
  • It provides clear information necessary for assuming personal and institutional responsibility in this area.
  • It avoids suspicions about members of the Congregation who have not committed abuse or have been wrongly accused..

Different Forms of Publication

Over the course of the 2020 calendar year, the General Directorate’s Interdepartmental Commission developed a policy for fair transparency and communication. The policy seeks to apply the criteria outlined in numbers 27 to 29 of Protect and Heal, and it establishes three forms for publishing cases of abuse committed by current and former Legionary priests. The policy’s primary aim is to enable the attainment of the goals indicated in the previous section, while respecting the legal requirements of each country.

The different forms are as follows:

Publication Using First and Last Name

Full names are employed for cases that occurred in countries that allow it or for cases that are already public.

Publication Using First Name Only

Only the first name is employed for cases involving those who have left the Congregation, since they are no longer under the responsibility of the Congregation and most of them do not exercise priestly ministry, and for those in which civil law does not allow the publication of surnames or abbreviations of surnames.

Publication Using a Numerical Code

Cases of priests have been published with a numerical code in the following circumstances:

1º When it is appropriate to take into account a victim’s reasoned request not to publish the priest’s name, because it could condition the healing process or the victim’s privacy.

2º When an applicable civil law explicitly prohibits the publication of someone’s name.

3º When a canonical or civil process is still in progress, since the right to the presumption of innocence prevails until guilt is established.

4º When the ends sought by publishing a priest’s name—namely, the victim’s healing, the restoration of justice, the reparation of scandal, the amendment of the abusing priest, and the prevention of future abuse—are met by other means. This only applies to cases typified by legislation as of minor gravity, when there is one known victim, and there are no well-founded indications that there might be others.

In cases under preliminary investigation (cf. canon 1717 of the Code of Canon Law), in principle, the name of the accused is not published beyond the requirements of the investigation itself.

Criteria for limited reinsertion of priests into pastoral ministry

In the Congregation of the Legionaries of Christ’s own norms, reinsertion into pastoral ministry is excluded «for any priest who is canonically declared guilty of having committed sexual abuse of a minor or vulnerable person» (Protect and Heal, 48). Therefore, limited reinsertion in the exercise of some priestly ministry can only be considered for someone who was not found guilty in an administrative or judicial process, that is, only for someone whose case was dealt with by measures of fraternal correction, reprimand or other means of pastoral solicitude according to c. 1341 of the Code of Canon Law (CIC) or with a penal precept (cf. c. 1319 CIC), having always observed the indications of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith (DDF).

The reinsertion into limited pastoral ministry of a priest who in the past has committed sexual abuse against a minor is a very grave responsibility, both for the Congregation and for the priest in question. The necessary conditions must be ensured so that the priest can carry out his service for the good of the people and, at the same time, the risks of harm must be avoided as far as humanly possible, and guarantees must be offered so that no further abuse will occur.

Considering this requirement, the General Director of the Legionaries of Christ, having consulted widely and having heard the opinion of his council, has established the following criteria for a possible reinsertion.

Concerning the priest in question:

  • The possibility of reintegration into pastoral service is not considered in the case of a priest canonically found guilty of having committed abuse or who is known – by canonical process, by admission or by disciplinary measures endorsed by the DDF – to have committed serial abuse, with multiple victims or of extreme gravity.
  • For those exceptional cases in which it is possible to consider a reintegration, the priest must:
  1. have agreed to follow a path of restorative justice, which entails acknowledging and taking responsibility for the harm caused, a willingness to make reparation to the victim and to seek true reconciliation with the victim and his family, as well as with others affected by the scandal; the path of restorative justice also involves facing possible civil or criminal consequences for his actions;
  2. to have followed a path of sincere repentance, conversion and reparation;
  3. to have a professional diagnosis that excludes that it is a structural problem;
  4. to have completed a therapeutic path that has led him/her to understand how he/she could have had these behaviors and also to identify and overcome the remote causes;
  5. to have a positive prognosis from an expert who has evaluated him on his reintegration into pastoral activity with the appropriate restrictions;
  6. to have confirmed and consolidated this positive prognosis within a prudential period established by the major superior, during which he will be able to collaborate in community and internal tasks and, if necessary, in some specific, appropriate and supervised ministerial assignments;
  7. to be able to communicate clearly to those who have religious or apostolic responsibility for him, the acts he has committed and the path he has followed, and to collaborate with the required communication to those who will receive his ministerial service;
  8.  to accept and comply with the restrictions for pastoral ministry with minors and, eventually, other restrictions (e.g., use of social networks, schedules, etc.), also to avoid the re-victimization of affected persons.
  9. In turn, the priest should be monitored and accompanied by the superior of the community, some members of the community, those responsible for his apostolate and the persons who work together with him or are appointed to observe his performance, who should have a sufficiently detailed knowledge of the case and of the restrictions and measures established.

In relation to the areas of work:

  1. Pastoral work with minors and vulnerable persons is excluded as well as other areas of work depending on the type of abuse committed and the result of the psychological evaluation;
  2. excluding houses of formation of the Congregation (cf. Protect and Heal, 49);
  3. places with a particular risk of scandal should be excluded;
  4. a stable, clearly defined and supervised environment should be sought for and provided;
  5. the group or community in which he ordinarily exercises some pastoral ministry should know his situation and be in agreement with it; they should be aware of the restrictions he has and, generically, the reasons for these restrictions;
  6. in any ministry, the priest should avoid the use of social networks and publications of any kind.

The eventual exercise of a restricted ministry, if authorized according to the above criteria, must be mentioned in the priest’s security plan. This plan, which is established for life for each priest who has committed abuse, comprehensively covers the various dimensions of his life and has an initial review and periodic (at least annual) evaluation and adjustments by the Territorial Review Committee, according to the Safe Environment Accreditation Standards (Accreditation Standards, Standard 19).

In addition, reintegration into pastoral ministry should consider adequate prior communication with the victim.

Last updated for Internet publication: May 26, 2022

Reparation program

  • Throughout the year 2021, as a complementary aspect to help with the integral process of healing already in place, the Congregation of the Legionaries of Christ has developed a guide to offer financial reparation and support to victims of sexual abuse of minors by members of the Congregation. It is the result of an international comparative study of other systems and parameters and is combined with civil and canonical procedures.

When a person has come into contact with one of the institutional channels for allegations or with an independent channel, these channels welcome and accompany the person. In addition to ensuring reporting and proceedings before civil and church authorities, the person affected by abuse will be assisted in recounting his or her experience, opting for counseling, and expressing any needs, including financial reparation. Whenever possible, reparation will take place in a broader process of restorative justice that seeks to contribute to the integral healing of the victim.

To this end, the Congregation has developed a reparation program that is stable over time and will be implemented progressively over the course of 2022 in the various countries we are present. This program consists of the elements illustrated in the graphic. The institutional channels in each place are available to offer any type of detailed explanation to the victims.

The Congregation is aware that no amount of reparation can make the harm caused by abuse disappear or compensate for it. However, it seeks to offer a comprehensive reparation to help bring justice and facilitate healing for the victim. The Congregation believes that financial reparation, along with care and accompaniment, can contribute to alleviating, at least in part, the burden carried by those who bear this wound.